Menu
When facing criminal charges, it feels like every decision is a matter of life and death. One choice you make now can have a lasting impact on your future. A plea deal can be tempting as it presents an easy opportunity for everything to just slow down or stop entirely. However, you may be wondering exactly what is a plea deal? Significantly, accepting a plea deal is a matter of give and take. Before you agree, it’s important to consider all of the terms and potential consequences.
Crime TV shows and movies have probably led you to believe that all criminal arrests and following charges build up to an epic courtroom battle between a prosecutor and defense attorney. Each side presents evidence and argues their version of events. Then, a jury of peers decides whether the accused is guilty.
The reality is that the criminal justice system is more complicated. Many people facing criminal charges never see their case go to trial. This is where a plea deal, plea offer, or plea agreement comes in. A plea deal is an agreement among the prosecutor, the individual criminal charged, and their criminal defense attorney. Generally, a defendant will agree to plead guilty to a specific set of charges in exchange for a concession from the prosecutor. The benefit given can vary, but some common concessions given include:
Prosecutors are not required to offer a plea deal in all situations. There is no federal or state constitutional right to plea bargaining. While a defendant may want and request one, the prosecutor doesn’t have to agree to it. Additionally, each plea deal is unique to the case. Prosecutors will consider factors such as the severity of the charges, the facts of the case, and the criminal history. A defendant is not required to accept a plea deal offered by the prosecutor.
The prosecutor has discretion to choose which type of plea deal they offer. New Jersey criminal law includes multiple types to address different types of circumstances. A charge bargain allows the defendant to plead guilty to a less serious charge than the one originally charged with. A sentence bargain requires the defendant to plead guilty to a lesser charge in exchange for a less severe sentence.
Count bargains may be used when the defendant is facing multiple charges. The prosecutor agrees to drop certain charges in exchange for the defendant pleading guilty to the remaining charges. A defendant may agree to plead guilty in exchange for the prosecution not pursuing aggravating factors as part of a fact bargain. Aggravating factors are elements that would typically merit an increased sentence.
If you’re faced with criminal charges, it’s essential not only to understand “what is a plea deal,” but you should also know how they work.
A prosecutor will only negotiate a plea deal with a defendant’s defense attorney or a defendant who has knowingly waived their right to legal counsel. The process typically begins when the prosecutor makes an offer. The offer may also come after negotiating with the defense attorney. The defense attorney and defendant will review the offer. Experienced criminal defense lawyers evaluate the terms against the evidence, charges, potential sentence, and available defenses. While they can advise their clients of the pros and cons, it's ultimately the defendant’s choice whether to accept or reject the plea deal.
If a defendant rejects the plea deal, their attorney may advocate for their client by responding with different terms. Another option is to reject and proceed with preparing for trial. If the defendant accepts the plea deal, it's submitted to the court for approval. A plea deal isn’t officially done until a judge approves the deal. Defendants entering a plea must certify that they understand the plea and are entering into it voluntarily without being pressured. Once the judge approves, the case typically proceeds to a sentencing hearing. If the judge rejects the agreement, a defendant is entitled to take back his plea without anything he previously said being used against him.
Accepting a plea deal may not be the best option for all defendants. Speaking with a criminal defense attorney can provide valuable legal insight when deciding if it's the right choice for your situation. Several factors can impact a defendant’s decision to accept or reject an offer.
The prosecution may have a substantial amount of strong evidence that supports the charges. The plea deal being offered could substantially reduce the severity of the charges or potential sentencing penalties. The agreement could significantly reduce the number of criminal charges by dismissing some of them. This dismissal could reduce the penalties the defendant faces.
A negotiated plea bargain could eliminate some of the uncertainty associated with a trial. By agreeing, the defendant can avoid a potentially substantially worse sentencing outcome if found guilty at trial. Depending on the case, that could include avoiding incarceration, protecting employment, limiting certain consequences, or resolving the case more quickly.
Just because a plea deal is better than the maximum possible sentence doesn’t automatically mean it’s worth accepting. Defendants should avoid making a decision based on fear or other emotions. Consulting with an experienced criminal defense attorney is critical before making this strategic decision.
When the prosecution’s evidence is minimal or weak, it could be the better option to reject the offer of a plea deal. Even if the prosecution does have evidence, there may be a way to suppress it or challenge the charges. In some situations, the plea deal doesn’t provide any valuable or meaningful benefit to the defendant.
Someone who believes they did not commit the offense should discuss the risks and alternatives with counsel before pleading guilty simply to avoid the uncertainty of trial. Additionally, pleading guilty can bring more severe consequences beyond the criminal sentencing penalty. The guilty plea could negatively impact employment, professional licensing, immigration status, firearms rights, or housing.
Plea deals aren’t a one-size-fits-all solution for individuals facing criminal charges. While it may make sense for one person to accept, it may not be the best option for someone else. A knowledgeable criminal defense lawyer can explain what is a plea deal and help ensure you make the best choice for your situation. At Lamparello Law, we advocate for our clients to secure the best possible outcome for their situation. That can include negotiating a plea deal or going to trial. Schedule a consultation with us today to discuss your criminal charges and plea bargain offer.
© 2026 Adam Lamparello, Esq.
| View Our Disclaimer | Privacy Policy
Law Firm Website Design by The Modern Firm